The story involves a new couple moving into a neighborhood, attempting to introduce themselves to a neighbor by bringing a pie. Initially, they are met with an unwelcoming response, as the neighbor rudely dismisses them. Feeling uncomfortable, the couple starts to leave. However, another neighbor warmly invites them into their home, showing a much friendlier attitude.

This story highlights the contrast between two types of neighbors—one who is unwelcoming and another who is open and hospitable. It reflects themes of first impressions, community, and kindness.