In this chaotic Thanksgiving preparation, tensions rise between Jenna and Roger over family traditions and how to host the holiday. Jenna wants to honor her late grandmother by cooking a traditional meal, but Roger's family dynamics complicate things. They argue about inviting their mothers, each highlighting the other's family's flaws—Jenna's mother being critical and Roger's mother being overly indulgent.

They ultimately decide to have one mother visit on Wednesday and the other on Thanksgiving Day to avoid conflict. As they prepare for the holiday, family members clash over kitchen duties and expectations, leading to comedic mishaps and misunderstandings. The couple grapples with finding a way to bring their families together while keeping the peace.