The story revolves around Jake and Alice, a couple grappling with their relationship and Jake's infidelity. Alice suggests getting matching tattoos as a sign of their love, but Jake, whose body is already covered in meaningful tattoos from his swimming career, dismisses the idea as silly.

At a coffee date with Melissa, a tattoo artist, Alice shares the backstory of her marriage and how they once got matching tattoos. Meanwhile, Jake's dishonesty is gradually revealed as he has been flirting with other women, including Margaret, who is also at the coffee shop. The tension builds when Alice confronts Jake about his behavior.

In a surprising twist, Alice decides to get a tattoo for Jake that reflects his betrayal—a tattoo with the date of their divorce. The story culminates in a dramatic confrontation where Alice asserts her independence, highlighting the themes of trust, betrayal, and self-empowerment.

Ultimately, the narrative captures the complexities of relationships and the impact of secrets, leaving Jake to face the consequences of his actions while Alice embraces her newfound strength.