In this story, Arthur, a dedicated student, is pressured by his classmate Billy to do his book report in exchange for getting back his own report. Despite his better judgment, Arthur completes the report for Billy, sacrificing his own work in the process. When it's time to present, Billy struggles because he hasn't read the book. Miss Henry confronts Billy after overhearing him bully Arthur and realizing he cheated. She then gives Arthur the opportunity to present his own report, allowing him to shine while Billy faces the consequences of his actions. The lesson emphasizes the importance of integrity and the idea that cheating ultimately leads to failure.