In this story, a group of kids plans to have some fun by targeting their neighbor, Miss Wheeler, a reclusive old woman rumored to be a witch. They initially plan to tease her by throwing items at her to provoke a reaction. Once she is distracted, they decide to toilet paper her house, thinking it would be a harmless prank.

However, the situation escalates as Miss Wheeler confronts them, and just as they think they’re getting away with it, one of the kids is caught by his mom, who expresses her disappointment in his behavior. The story explores themes of peer pressure, the consequences of bullying, and the importance of making responsible choices.