The story follows James, who has a shallow perspective on dating, focusing mainly on physical appearance. His friends set him up with Cindy, a nurse with a big heart, but when they finally meet, James is shocked to discover that she doesn't match his expectations based on looks. He initially dismisses her, calling her "fat" and fails to appreciate her personality, which he had connected with over the phone.

His friends confront him about his superficial views, emphasizing that true beauty lies within. Despite their encouragement, James remains judgmental and rude. Ultimately, Cindy stands her ground, revealing James's ugly character and reinforcing the message that true value comes from who someone is, not how they look. The story highlights the importance of looking beyond physical attributes and recognizing inner beauty.