Peyton is heartbroken after her boyfriend Zack dumps her, so she seeks refuge at her best friend Milo's place. Milo is now dating Olivia, who feels uncomfortable with Peyton’s presence due to her close history with Milo. As they spend time together, tensions rise when Olivia becomes suspicious of Peyton's intentions, and Peyton expresses lingering feelings for Milo.

An argument ensues between the three, where Peyton tries to convince Milo to choose her over Olivia. Ultimately, Milo reaffirms his commitment to Olivia, leading to Peyton leaving in anger. The story ends with Milo and Olivia reconciling, deciding to focus on their relationship and moving past the drama.