The story revolves around Laura, a high school student who is leading a double life by dating two boys, Zach and Jason, while lying to them and using Jason primarily for help with her homework. As she struggles with her secrets, her father, Mr. Hartley, grows suspicious of her behavior and becomes determined to find out what’s really going on.

After witnessing Laura with both boys at school, Mr. Hartley confronts her, revealing that he knows about her dishonesty. This leads to a dramatic confrontation where both boys express their hurt and disappointment. Realizing the impact of her lies, Laura feels remorseful and acknowledges her mistakes, especially regarding her relationship with her father.

Mr. Hartley emphasizes the importance of honesty and trust, explaining that while mistakes are part of growing up, it’s essential to take responsibility for one’s actions. He encourages Laura to confess to her teacher about cheating and reassures her that while trust is hard to rebuild, he believes she can learn from this experience. The story concludes with them reaffirming their love for each other, despite the challenges, and Laura accepting the consequences of her actions.