In this comedic school story, Mrs. Dale, a teacher using a confusing "muddle method," assigns her students reports on their favorite teacher. Many students miss the deadline and receive failing grades, leading to summer school, which threatens their planned European trip. Principal Winston intervenes, recognizes the flaws in Mrs. Dale's teaching, and allows the students to pass, while demoting her to lunch lady. The story highlights the importance of effective teaching and the consequences of chaotic methods.