A group of kids, led by Kevin, plans to prank their neighbors, the Lebowskis, by ringing their doorbell and leaving moldy oranges on the porch. However, their prank goes awry when Mr. Lebowski slips on the oranges, resulting in a serious injury. The kids panic, thinking they've caused a tragedy, but when they visit the Lebowskis with banana bread to apologize, they discover that the Lebowskis orchestrated the whole scenario to scare them into stopping their pranks. The parents are involved, leading to a humorous lesson about the consequences of pranking others.