Handsome and wealthy Kyle Kingson values appearance above all else, humiliating classmates for being ugly. When he becomes president, Kendra, shamed as a witch, is outraged. To prove he's not shallow, Kyle invites her to a party, where a girl criticizes him for his behavior. Rejected, Kyle turns to Lindy, whom Kendra recommended for president. Unaware of Lindy's long-standing crush on him, they take a photo together for the school newspaper. Despite initial shyness, a connection is formed between Kyle and Lindy.