The show starts in a high school lunchroom with Taylor, a blonde teen, being bullied by classmates. The head cheerleader kicks her out, leaving Taylor with April. They fight, leading to a supernatural attack by April. Later, Sam helps Taylor, suspecting a demon possession. Flashback to 1997 shows Sam and Dean's past at Truman High and their bond. In the present, Dean, disguised as Coach Ron, investigates demonic activity at the school. Sam realizes no threat exists and suggests leaving.