In "I Can't Look at a Boy in the Eye: Part 2," Sarah has learned to manage her ability to spark instant infatuation in boys, but it complicates her social life. When she meets Ethan, a boy seemingly immune to her charm, she becomes intrigued and determined to connect with him. As she navigates her awkwardness around him, Sarah discovers that Ethan values authenticity, prompting her to confront her fears about vulnerability. Their growing friendship helps her realize that true relationships go beyond mere attraction, leading to a heartwarming journey of self-discovery and genuine connection.