FULL VIDEO REVIEW:

Concept2 Model D

Overview

The Concept2 Model D is a widely recognized rowing machine known for its durability, accuracy, and performance. It's a favorite among both casual users and serious athletes.

Features

• Air Resistance: Uses a fan flywheel to create resistance, allowing users to adjust intensity based on their rowing speed.
• Performance Monitor: Equipped with a PM5 monitor that tracks distance, pace, calories burned, and stroke rate, providing detailed performance data.
• Adjustable Footrests: Footrests can accommodate a wide range of shoe sizes for comfort.
• Modular Design: Can be easily separated into two pieces for storage and transportation.
• Durability: Built from high-quality materials, ensuring it can withstand heavy use.

Pros

• Excellent for high-intensity workouts with customizable resistance.
• Accurate performance tracking via the PM5 monitor.
• Highly durable and built for longevity.
• Easily stores away when not in use.

Cons

• The air resistance may be noisy compared to water rowing machines.
• The design is more utilitarian, which some users may find less visually appealing.

FULL VIDEO REVIEW:

WaterRower Natural

Overview

The WaterRower Natural offers a unique rowing experience that simulates the feel of rowing on water. Its aesthetic appeal and smooth operation make it a popular choice for home gyms.

Features

• Water Resistance: Utilizes a water tank to create resistance, providing a smooth and realistic rowing experience.
• Natural Wood Construction: Made from solid ash wood, giving it a beautiful finish and adding to the aesthetic of any space.
• Performance Monitor: Comes with a S4 monitor that tracks time, distance, stroke rate, and calories burned, though it may not be as detailed as the PM5 on the Concept2.
• Silent Operation: The water resistance mechanism operates quietly, making it suitable for use in shared spaces.
• Space-Saving Design: Can be stored vertically to save space.

Pros

• Offers a realistic rowing experience with water resistance.
• Quiet operation makes it suitable for home environments.
• Attractive wooden design enhances home aesthetics.
• Smooth and fluid motion during workouts.

Cons

• Requires periodic water maintenance to ensure proper resistance.
• Generally higher price point compared to the Concept2.
• The monitor may not provide as much detailed data as the concept2 PM5

FULL VIDEO REVIEW:

Key Comparisons

Resistance Type:

Concept2 Model D: Air resistance, which adjusts based on rowing intensity.

WaterRower Natural: Water resistance, providing a smooth and natural rowing experience.

Performance Monitoring:

Concept2 Model D: PM5 monitor offers extensive tracking capabilities and data accuracy.

WaterRower Natural: S4 monitor tracks basic metrics but may lack some of the detailed insights of the PM5.

Build Quality and Design:

Concept2 Model D: Sturdy and functional, designed for durability and performance.

WaterRower Natural: Aesthetically pleasing wooden construction, offering a more luxurious look.

Noise Level:

Concept2 Model D: Can be noisy due to the air resistance mechanism.

WaterRower Natural: Operates quietly, making it ideal for home use.

Maintenance:

Concept2 Model D: Low maintenance; primarily requires occasional cleaning.

WaterRower Natural: Needs water level maintenance and occasional cleaning of the tank.

Conclusion

Choosing between the Concept2 Model D and WaterRower Natural ultimately comes down to your personal preferences and fitness goals:

Choose Concept2 Model D: If you’re looking for a reliable, durable rowing machine with advanced performance tracking, adjustable resistance for high-intensity workouts, and you don’t mind a utilitarian design.

Choose WaterRower Natural: If you want a visually appealing, quieter rowing machine that provides a realistic rowing experience and you appreciate the aesthetics of wood, and you don’t mind the extra maintenance involved.

Both machines excel in their own right, so consider your priorities to find the best fit for your rowing needs!