S-Pen vs. Apple Pencil: iPad Pro M1 vs. Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra Review

FULL VIDEO REVIEW:

Overview:

The iPad Pro M1 paired with the Apple Pencil and the Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra with the S-Pen are two popular choices for users seeking a premium tablet experience with advanced stylus support. Both the Apple Pencil and the S-Pen are designed for precise writing, drawing, and digital interaction, but they cater to different user needs and preferences. Here’s how they compare on the iPad Pro M1 and Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra.

Apple Pencil Features:

The Apple Pencil is designed to integrate seamlessly with the iPad Pro’s M1 chip, providing responsive, pixel-perfect precision. It includes pressure and tilt sensitivity, which artists and note-takers appreciate for detailed drawing and smooth handwriting. The second-generation Apple Pencil also magnetically attaches to the iPad Pro for easy charging and storage. Features like "Scribble," which converts handwritten text to typed text, enhance the user experience in iPadOS, making it a versatile tool for creatives and professionals alike.

S-Pen Features:

The Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra’s S-Pen offers a natural writing feel with low latency, especially when paired with Samsung’s AMOLED display. It also includes customizable gestures, air actions, and Bluetooth connectivity, enabling users to control presentations or navigate the device with remote commands. Unlike the Apple Pencil, the S-Pen comes included with the Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra, adding value for users. Samsung’s software, particularly in Samsung Notes, has comprehensive handwriting-to-text options and powerful note organization features, making it a strong choice for productivity.

Comparison of Key Aspects:

• Latency and Responsiveness: Both the Apple Pencil and S-Pen offer impressive, near-zero latency, though the iPad Pro's M1 chip provides an ultra-smooth experience that rivals traditional pen-and-paper feel. The Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra’s 120Hz refresh rate works effectively with the S-Pen for fluid writing and drawing.
• Pressure Sensitivity: Both styluses support pressure sensitivity, although Apple’s precision tends to feel more natural for intricate line work, while the S-Pen’s sensitivity is customizable for different styles.
• Battery and Charging: The Apple Pencil needs to be charged, but it attaches magnetically to the iPad Pro for wireless charging. In contrast, the S-Pen does not require regular charging except for air actions, where it charges quickly by attaching to the tablet’s magnetic strip.
• Additional Features: The S-Pen’s air gestures and remote control features add extra functionality beyond drawing and note-taking. In contrast, the Apple Pencil focuses solely on drawing and writing, providing simplicity but fewer secondary functions.

Pros and Cons:

Apple Pencil Pros:

• Seamless integration with iPadOS and M1 chip for enhanced precision.
• Great for professional artists and designers.
• Magnetic attachment and wireless charging.

Apple Pencil Cons:

• Requires separate purchase.
• Lacks multifunctionality like remote control or gestures.

S-Pen Pros:

• Comes included with the Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra.
• Air gestures and remote commands enhance multitasking.
• Excellent note-taking features within Samsung Notes.

S-Pen Cons:

• Slightly less intuitive for advanced art compared to the Apple Pencil.
• Some features require charging via the tablet.

Conclusion:

If you’re a professional artist or prioritize simplicity and precision, the Apple Pencil paired with the iPad Pro M1 is hard to beat. However, for users who value additional functionality, the S-Pen on the Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra is a feature-rich alternative with versatile productivity capabilities. Both options deliver a top-tier experience—your best choice depends on how you plan to use the tablet.