M1 Mac vs. Intel PC for Photo and Video Editing

FULL VIDEO:

Performance with Editing Software

M1 Mac:

• Adobe Lightroom and Capture One: The M1 Mac, particularly in the M1 Pro and M1 Max configurations, offers efficient handling of high-resolution RAW images, with smooth performance in Lightroom and Capture One. These apps are optimized for Apple Silicon, translating to fast exports, real-time previews, and minimal lag.
• DaVinci Resolve and Final Cut Pro: Apple Silicon provides excellent performance in video editing, particularly in Final Cut Pro, which is built specifically for macOS and M1 chips. DaVinci Resolve has also been optimized for M1, with impressive rendering speeds, playback stability, and color grading performance, especially in ProRes and H.265 workflows.
• Battery Efficiency: M1 Macs are highly power-efficient, meaning less heat and fan noise during heavy tasks and impressive battery life for on-the-go editing.

Intel PC:

• Adobe Lightroom and Capture One: Intel PCs perform well in both Lightroom and Capture One, with high-end models capable of handling RAW images and complex edits smoothly. PCs also offer greater compatibility with plug-ins and third-party tools, making them versatile for photo editors.
• DaVinci Resolve and Other Video Software: DaVinci Resolve performs well on high-spec Intel systems, especially those with a dedicated GPU, allowing for powerful rendering and effects. However, Final Cut Pro is unavailable for Windows, which may limit professional video editors looking to use it.
• Hardware Upgrade Flexibility: PCs offer flexibility in upgrading components like GPUs and RAM, allowing users to keep up with software demands. However, this can sometimes lead to compatibility and optimization issues compared to the M1’s unified architecture.

Pros

M1 Mac:

• Optimized for Apple Silicon: Many software applications are optimized for the M1, meaning seamless performance without compatibility issues.
• High Efficiency: Lower power consumption with strong thermal management.
• Seamless macOS Integration: macOS is known for its stability and efficiency, especially with native apps like Final Cut Pro.

Intel PC:

• Upgradeable Hardware: Ability to customize hardware based on needs, such as adding RAM or upgrading GPUs.
• Broader Software Compatibility: PCs run a wider range of software, providing flexibility for editors using Windows-only tools or specific plug-ins.
• GPU Options for Heavy Lifting: Access to high-end GPUs, which benefit programs like DaVinci Resolve with CUDA acceleration for faster rendering.

Cons

M1 Mac:

• Limited Upgradability: M1 Macs have fixed hardware, so future upgrades are limited to buying a new machine.
• Fewer GPU Options: M1 Macs rely on integrated GPUs, which may not match the power of top-tier discrete GPUs in some tasks.
• Software Compatibility: While macOS software options are extensive, some PC-exclusive tools and plug-ins may not be available.

Intel PC:

• Efficiency and Battery Life: PCs generally have shorter battery life and may run hotter and louder.
• Operating System Constraints: Windows may not run certain macOS-exclusive software like Final Cut Pro.
• Potential Compatibility Issues: Custom builds or hardware upgrades can occasionally lead to software compatibility issues.

Benefits

• M1 Mac is ideal for editors who work with Final Cut Pro or prefer a streamlined, all-in-one setup with minimal power consumption and heat, making it excellent for mobile professionals.
• Intel PC shines in flexibility and power, especially for users who need high-end GPU capabilities, more customization options, or Windows-exclusive software for editing.

Conclusion

In 2024, the Apple M1 Mac is a powerful choice for creators looking for high efficiency, streamlined workflows, and macOS-specific tools like Final Cut Pro. However, if you need extensive hardware flexibility, GPU options, or run Windows-exclusive software, a high-spec Intel PC could be a better fit.

• Choose M1 Mac for best integration with macOS applications and Apple Silicon-optimized programs.
• Choose Intel PC if you need advanced GPU support, customization potential, or compatibility with a wider range of editing tools.