It’s completely understandable that you're feeling upset in this situation, especially with the dynamic you’ve described between your boyfriend and his ex. Your feelings are valid, and it’s important to acknowledge and explore them without dismissing them as mere jealousy. Relationships can be complex, and it's natural to feel uncomfortable when your partner’s past relationships (romantic or platonic) seem to have such a strong presence in your current one.

1. Assessing the Friendship and Banter

It’s clear that your boyfriend and his ex, Emma, share a deep bond, and from your perspective, the playful, bantering dynamic may feel inappropriate or even threatening, especially in the context of your Christmas gathering. It’s understandable that you’d feel uncomfortable when they seem to be dominating the conversation and engaging in behavior that feels intimate or overly familiar, particularly when it’s in front of you. This might bring up insecurities about your place in his life or make you question whether your relationship can measure up to theirs.

Playful interactions like banter can be innocent between friends, but when they come across as overly intimate or if they overshadow your own connection with your partner, it can understandably make you feel left out or less important. In this case, it’s worth reflecting on whether the banter feels emotionally exclusive or whether it’s simply their way of interacting. However, the fact that this behavior made you uncomfortable signals that it may be crossing a line for you.

2. Balancing Jealousy and Boundaries

It’s great that you're acknowledging your own jealousy and working on it. Jealousy itself isn’t inherently bad—it’s a natural emotion—but it’s important to address it in a healthy way. Since you mentioned that you're friends with an ex and have been able to manage those relationships without drama, it's likely not the concept of his friendship with Emma that bothers you, but the intensity of it.

What seems to be bothering you is not just their closeness, but how it impacts you—it feels like their bond is stronger, or more playful, than yours. This is an important feeling to explore because it can help identify specific boundaries that need to be set in your relationship to make both you and your boyfriend feel respected and secure.

3. Understanding the Root of Your Feelings

It may be helpful to break down your feelings into more specific concerns. For example:

• Feeling Left Out: You mentioned that their banter and playfulness made you question your alignment with your boyfriend. It’s possible that you felt excluded or left out in the moment. Feeling sidelined in a group setting can be hard, especially when it's your partner and his ex taking up much of the emotional space.
• Insecurity About Their Bond: It’s also possible that the closeness they share makes you feel like you don’t have the same level of connection with your boyfriend. When we see others connect in a way that feels so natural or effortless, it can lead us to question whether we have that same depth of connection with our own partner.
• Concerns About Emotional Intimacy: Their deep emotional bond and the fact that she’s still his “first call” might make you feel uncertain about how much emotional space you take up in his life. You’re right in that it’s not the friendship itself but the intensity of it that is challenging.
• 
  

4. Communicating with Your Boyfriend

The key to addressing this situation lies in open, honest communication with your boyfriend. If you haven’t already, it might be helpful to share how you feel in a calm, non-accusatory way. You could try framing it as your own emotional experience rather than criticizing him or Emma. For example:

“I want to be honest about how I’ve been feeling when I see you interact with Emma. I know you two share a long and special bond, but sometimes the playfulness and how much attention it takes up can make me feel a bit left out or like I’m not as connected with you. It’s not about mistrusting your friendship, but it does stir up some insecurities in me. I just want to feel like we have our own special connection too.”

This approach helps him understand that your feelings aren’t about his friendship but rather how certain behaviors affect you in your relationship. It gives him a chance to respond, and it may open up a conversation about setting boundaries that make both of you feel secure.

5. Setting Healthy Boundaries

If your boyfriend understands your feelings and acknowledges them, you may be able to find a middle ground. For example, it might help to set some boundaries about how they interact when you’re present. Maybe you need a little more space where their inside jokes or playfulness don’t dominate the atmosphere, especially in group settings like family gatherings. You might request that they be mindful of how their interactions affect you, which can go a long way in making you feel more included and less like you’re competing for attention.

Additionally, exploring your own insecurities and jealousy with a therapist or through self-reflection can help you manage those feelings in a constructive way. It’s important that you also feel secure in your bond with your boyfriend, and finding ways to nurture that connection can help you feel more confident in your relationship overall.

6. Conclusion

It’s natural to feel uncomfortable when your partner’s ex is still a large presence in their life, especially when their dynamic appears playful or intimate. What matters most is how this dynamic makes you feel and whether it aligns with your own emotional needs and boundaries in the relationship. Open communication, understanding each other’s perspectives, and finding boundaries that respect both your relationship and his friendship can help you navigate this challenge. This isn’t just about jealousy but about feeling secure and valued in your connection with him.

The key is to address your feelings in a way that doesn’t dismiss your own experience or make you feel like you’re overreacting, while also respecting his history with Emma.