It sounds like you are in a very challenging situation, and it's understandable to feel overwhelmed given the emotional stakes involved. Here are some considerations and steps you can take to navigate this delicate circumstance.

1. Self-Reflection:

Before making any decisions, take some time to reflect on your feelings for each woman. Ask yourself the following questions:

• What do I truly want in a partner? Consider the qualities and values that matter most to you in a long-term relationship.
• What are my long-term goals? At 55, think about your goals regarding marriage and children. Are you ready for that commitment again?
• How do I envision my life in the future? Picture your life in a few years. Who do you see by your side?

2. Evaluate Your Relationships:

It's important to assess what each woman brings into your life:

• Woman 1 (23 years old): She seems vibrant and fun, but consider the potential challenges of a significant age gap and her emotional readiness for a serious commitment. Her statement about coping if it doesn't work out is also a red flag; it indicates a high level of dependency on the relationship.
• Woman 2 (32 years old): She appears to have more life experience and stability in some areas, but her financial struggles and caretaker role may impact her availability and emotional bandwidth. Think about how her responsibilities might affect your relationship.

3. Communicate Openly:

Once you have clarity on your feelings, it’s crucial to communicate honestly with both women:

• Set up a time to talk with each of them, ensuring you provide a safe and private environment for this discussion.
• Express your feelings candidly. Let them know that you care about them but that you are feeling conflicted.
• Avoid making promises you can't keep. It’s important to be transparent about your uncertainties.

4. Consider the Impact of Your Decision:

Think about the potential outcomes of choosing one woman over the other:

• How will each woman handle the news? Recognize that both may experience significant emotional distress.
• Are you prepared to support either of them if they need time to process their feelings?

5. Take Your Time:

While you feel urgency, it's important to take the time you need to make the right decision. You don’t want to rush into a commitment that you might regret later. Consider suggesting a temporary pause in the relationship with both women while you sort out your feelings.

6. Seek Professional Guidance:

If you find yourself struggling to navigate these feelings, consider speaking to a counselor or therapist. They can provide a neutral perspective and help you work through your emotions and the implications of your choices.

Conclusion:

Ultimately, the decision will come down to what aligns best with your values, desires, and life goals. Remember, it’s okay to prioritize your well-being and seek a relationship that fulfills you. Whatever path you choose, approach it with empathy and honesty to minimize hurt for everyone involved.

Take care of yourself during this process, and remember that open communication is key to navigating complex emotional landscapes.